The Unfair Reality of College Football Awards
The inevitable fate of the Group of 5 schools in college football is a topic of discussion that cannot be avoided. While it’s not a desirable outcome, it’s clear that the powers that be are inclined to marginalize these institutions. The recent snubbing of Harold Fannin Jr., a tight end from Bowling Green, is a prime example of this phenomenon.
A Historic Season Ignored
Fannin Jr. had an unprecedented season, leading all tight ends in over 20 offensive categories and finishing with the second-most yards among all receivers. Despite these impressive statistics, he was overlooked for the John Mackey Award, which is given to the nation’s top tight end. It’s difficult to comprehend how a player who dominated his position can be ignored by voters.
The Competition Factor
Penn State fans will argue that Tyler Warren, the award winner, played against tougher competition. However, Fannin Jr. put up impressive numbers against Penn State and Texas A&M, while Warren failed to reach 100 yards against a ranked opponent. Additionally, Warren had the benefit of playing with a 5-star quarterback, which undoubtedly contributed to his success.
Unfair Assumptions
Warren’s supporters will claim that Fannin Jr. is a glorified wide receiver, despite having no evidence to support this assertion. In reality, Fannin Jr. is an exceptional blocker, as evidenced by his run blocking grade, which far surpasses Warren’s.
What Could Have Been
Bowling Green’s failure to utilize Fannin Jr. in the wildcat formation may have cost him the award. Warren’s ability to run the ball effectively and score touchdowns in the red zone gave him an edge that Fannin Jr. didn’t have. If Bowling Green had incorporated Fannin Jr. into their wildcat package, the outcome might have been different.
The Politics of College Football
It’s clear that college football values potential and talent over actual performance. This mindset is reflected in the voting process for awards like the John Mackey Award. Voters tend to favor players from power conferences, even if their statistics don’t justify the recognition.
A Rare Exception
Kudos to the Walter Camp Football Foundation and PFF, who recognized Fannin Jr.’s exceptional season by naming him a 1st Team All-American and rating him as the highest player in college football, respectively.
Disappointment and Frustration
As a fan of a MAC school, it’s disheartening to see a deserving player like Fannin Jr. overlooked. The fact that the John Mackey Award voters include individuals with clear biases and limited knowledge of non-power conference players only adds to the frustration.
A Bright Future Ahead
Despite the snub, Tyler Warren is an incredible player who will have a successful NFL career. He deserves recognition, but not at the expense of a more deserving player like Harold Fannin Jr.
Leave a Reply