2024 MLB Playoffs: Overreactions Judged

Overreactions Abound in the MLB Playoffs

The baseball world is abuzz with excitement as the 2024 postseason heats up. With two rounds already in the books, it’s time to take a step back and assess the state of the teams still vying for a World Series berth. Let’s examine some of the overreactions making the rounds and separate fact from fiction.

The Dodgers are Unbeatable… Not So Fast

Los Angeles’ dominant Game 1 victory against the New York Mets has many declaring them the team to beat. While they do look strong, let’s not forget that they were facing elimination just a week ago against the San Diego Padres. Their relief pitching, although excellent, is vulnerable, and injuries have taken a toll on their starting rotation. The Dodgers are good, but not invincible.

Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani: Built for October

Despite some lackluster postseason performances, these two superstars are not suddenly rendered ineffective in the playoffs. Judge’s career numbers may dip slightly in October, but he remains one of the game’s most feared hitters. Ohtani, meanwhile, showed signs of life in Game 1 against the Mets after a slow start to the postseason. These two are built to hit, regardless of the month.

The Mets’ Mojo Hasn’t Expired

New York’s resounding loss to the Dodgers in Game 1 has some wondering if their magic has worn off. However, this team has consistently shown an ability to bounce back from adversity. Don’t count them out just yet, especially considering the Dodgers’ bullpen-heavy approach in Game 2.

Hot Closer vs. Great Closer: A False Dichotomy

The debate rages on about whether a hot closer like Luke Weaver or a proven great closer like Emmanuel Clase is more valuable. The answer lies somewhere in between. Both pitchers have their strengths and can be effective in different situations. It’s not necessarily a question of either-or, but rather how each team utilizes their respective closers.

The Phillies’ Window is Closing

Philadelphia’s regression over the past two Octobers is a concern, and their aging core doesn’t bode well for future

Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *